How to disclose AI use in manuscripts and grants: Your trainees already use AI. Whether they tell you depends on you.Today’s newsletter is brought to you by: Somewhere between 28% and 76% of researchers tell surveys they use AI when they prepare a manuscript. When BMJ Group made the disclosure question mandatory across 49 journals, 5.7% of 25,114 submissions reported any AI use. Different samples from different years. But a gap that wide still needs an explanation. And researchers have already given one. Oxford University Press surveyed 2,606 researchers this year. Of the journal authors, 46% said they had not fully disclosed their AI use in the past year.
The stigma of AI use unfortunately runs deep in academia. A longer policy will not close that gap. The people who can close it run labs, divisions, and institutions. 👋🏽 Quick announcement: Our Black Friday deal for Research Boost (AI academic writing agent) is live. Use code RBBLACKFRI20 to get 20% OFF for 12 months on both monthly and yearly plans: https://researchboost.com/pricing 1. The disclosure gap comes from fear, and the fear has evidenceTwo more measurements point the same way.
The fear is partly justified. Schilke and Reimann ran 13 experiments with more than 5,000 participants and found that disclosing AI use lowered trust. But trust fell furthest when the authors did not disclose and a third party exposed the AI use later. At a recent NIH K Forum, the NIH officials were comfortable with AI as long as the ideas and the science belong to the researcher. However, the researchers I spoke with afterward were far more resistant. They felt “disappointed” and even “disgusted” that their trainees or colleagues used AI. The written rules are calmer than the hallway. Closing that distance is a leadership job. 2. Lab leaders set the norm before any policy doesTrainees learn what is acceptable by watching you. If you never mention AI, they conclude it is something to hide. A senior colleague was angry that a mentee had looked up a method in ChatGPT, which invented one. The mentee skipped one step, which was checking the output against a source. In a group where AI use is shameful, nobody teaches that step. You learn someone is using the tool only at the moment it breaks. Four habits change that:
Then write it down in a one-page lab SOP: approved tools, data rules, a shared AI log, and the disclosure templates below. 3. The message from the top decides whether people hideData security deserves serious attention. So does research ethics. Patient data, unpublished results, and confidential reviews do not belong in a consumer chatbot. The tone of the message matters as much as the rule. "AI tools are blocked" and "here is the approved tool, here is the data you can put in it, and here is who to ask" protect the same data. Only the second keeps the use where you can see it. (Also, that internal AI tool needs to be as good or better than the available alternatives for people to actually use it.) A University of Melbourne study with KPMG >48,000 people, found that 57% of employees conceal their AI use and pass off AI-generated work as their own. Only 40% said their workplace had any policy or guidance on generative AI. If you are a chair, a dean, or a research office, a useful message has three parts:
A blanket block pushes the use underground, where nobody can teach it or check it. 4. People will not share a workflow they think will replace themPicture your research coordinator. She has built an AI workflow for chart screening that carries a decade of knowing which records cause trouble. That is tacit knowledge, written down in a form a machine can run. Now ask what happens to her job if she shows you. In the 2024 Work Trend Index from Microsoft and LinkedIn, a survey of 31,000 knowledge workers, 53% of AI users feared that leaning on it for important tasks would make them look replaceable. Ethan Mollick names the same worry in his new book Co-Existence. People suspect they are training their own replacements, so silence is the rational choice. His advice to leaders is to reduce that fear directly: guarantee that nobody is laid off as a result of AI use, and reward the people who share what they built. Assurance has to be explicit:
A PI cannot promise what a hospital or a dean controls. Promise what you do control, and carry the same request up the chain. Leadership carries real weight while this terrain is still uncertain. Disclosure is the working part. It is how we keep the boundaries visible, how we learn from each other, and how we move the science forward with AI. 5. What journals require: three principles and a locationSet the stigma aside and read what publishers and standards bodies have written. For manuscripts, most policies reduce to 3 principles:
Where the disclosure goes varies by journal. It usually lands in a dedicated AI declaration, the Acknowledgments (for writing help), the Methods (for research tasks), or some combination. ICMJE also wants it in your cover letter. The stakes are stated plainly. The ICMJE section for authors says nondisclosure "may be construed as misconduct in some circumstances." Current journal policies (as of Nov 2026)3 things to highlight:
AI-generated imagesThis is a big change. AI-generated images were strictly prohibited until earlier this year.
For data figures, assume no. For explanatory figures, check the journal first. I expected these rules to loosen as image models improved. It is starting to happen. Always follow the target journal's instructions. They override everything here, and they are changing fast. 6. What funders require: originality firstFor grants, the weight falls on originality. Funders want to know you did not outsource your ideas, and they hold you fully responsible for what you submit. Some funders specify where the disclosure goes. Others state the principle and stop there: AI use cannot compromise originality, confidentiality, or accuracy. Funder policies side by sideThe direction is that of more transparency. 7. The hard line: confidential peer reviewThis is where I see people step into real risk by accident. Grant applications and manuscripts under review contain confidential, proprietary, and unpublished information. The rules here are the strictest of all.
Reviewing your own work is different. Using AI to criticize your own study, to point out flaws, stress-test arguments, and find weak spots, is one of the best uses I know. I would never do it on a free chatbot plan. Free means you pay with your data. Use a paid or institutional subscription and turn off the setting that lets your chats train the model. The safest option is an open-weight model such as Llama or DeepSeek running locally on your own device. DO NOT use their website or app - that does not count as local. 8. How to write the disclosureEvery AI disclosure should answer 3 important questions:
Then put it where it belongs:
Fill-in templatesA. Light editing (Acknowledgments) "During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [TOOL, VERSION (MONTH YEAR)] to improve the grammar and readability of author-written text. The authors reviewed every change and take full responsibility for the content." Elsevier requires no statement for basic grammar, spelling, and punctuation checks. For ICMJE and Springer Nature journals, include it. B. Drafting help (Acknowledgments or AI declaration) "[TOOL, VERSION (MONTH YEAR)] was used to [restructure / produce a first draft of / summarize the literature for] the [SECTION] from the authors' outline and notes. The authors rewrote the text, checked every reference against its original source, and take full responsibility for the final manuscript." The phrase "from the authors' outline and notes" carries weight. At Springer Nature it separates Amber from Red. C. Code (Methods) "Analysis code in [R / Python, VERSION] was drafted with help from [TOOL, VERSION (MONTH YEAR)]. [INITIALS] reviewed every line, tested it against [manual calculations / a reference dataset], and verified all results. Prompts and final code are available in [SUPPLEMENTARY FILE / REPOSITORY]." Elsevier published its own declaration template. It follows the same principles: the tool, the reason, and a sentence confirming that the authors reviewed and edited the output and take full responsibility for the article. Copy the exact wording from their page when submitting to an Elsevier journal. Two worked examplesSystematic review: "GPT-6 Astra (ChatGPT, September 2026) assisted in refining the search strategy. Covidence and Rayyan supported abstract screening, and [EXTRACTION TOOL, VERSION] prepopulated structured data fields. PK and DP manually reviewed and verified every AI-assisted step. R code drafted with AI aided the statistical analysis, and RP verified all results for accuracy and reproducibility." Manuscript writing: "During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used Claude Opus 4.8 (June 2026) to refine the structure, improve clarity, and strengthen the coherence of the argument. The same model was used to summarize literature, and the authors critically reviewed, revised, and expanded those summaries. All factual claims and references were independently verified, and the final manuscript reflects the intellectual contribution and judgment of the authors." Both statements do 3 things:
A good AI disclosure statement does all three. 5 mistakes to avoid
Pro tip: Log the tool, the version, and the task on the day you use it. You will not reconstruct it six months later at submission. Barely a third of researchers in the OUP survey keep that record. Start with one sentence in your own labIf you lead a group, tell them this week which AI tools you use and how you check the output. Then ask them the same. If you are a trainee or a staff member, start your AI log today and bring one workflow to your next lab meeting. I would love to know how this looks where you work. Does your lab talk about AI use openly, or does everyone find out when something breaks? I read every message (no bots involved :). Top Papers on AI in research this week:
Top Papers on AI in education this week:
The post How to disclose AI use in manuscripts and grants: Your trainees already use AI. Whether they tell you depends on you appeared first on Rising Researcher Academy. |