AI Just Wrote 700+ Math Papers. Will It Replace Researchers?Today’s newsletter is brought to you by: At the Mayo Clinic Rheumatology Centennial Celebration, someone in the audience asked a question I have not stopped thinking about. "What's the point in teaching the next generation of doctors and researchers when AI can do it all?" AI writes, codes, and summarizes faster than most of us. This fall, it also did something many mathematicians thought was decades away. I think that math story, read carefully, is one of the strongest arguments for training more researchers, not fewer.
👋🏽 Quick announcement: Research Boost 2.0 is live. It is an AI academic writing agent that works with you on your research. Try it here: https://researchboost.com/ 1. Five weeks that shook mathematicsOn September 8, OpenAI announced that roughly 10,000 AI agents running on an unreleased model had shown that the Navier-Stokes equations, which describe how fluids flow, can blow up. That question is one of the Clay Institute's $1 million Millennium Prize Problems. The proof took about 88 hours and was checked in Lean, a programming language that verifies proofs line by line. Four weeks later, OpenAI released 722 manuscripts covering 372 families of results. Each took about three hours of model thinking time, and nearly every one came from a single prompt handed to a single agent. I will be honest. I do not understand most of this math. Math like this is one of the reasons I chose a biology major in undergrad. So I read the coverage the way most of you will, trying to work out what it means for the rest of us. Many mathematicians reacted with anger. One group called the release a demonstration of power rather than scholarship. Within a day, OpenAI withdrew three of the manuscripts. A single sign error had invalidated one paper and the construction two others were built on. 2. What mathematicians are actually worried aboutMany commenters assumed mathematicians were simply afraid for their jobs. The deeper worry applies to every researcher. In 1735, Leonhard Euler solved a puzzle with no practical value. Could you walk across all seven bridges of Königsberg without crossing any bridge twice? The answer was no, and nobody needs it today. What mattered was how Euler got there. He stripped the city down to land masses and connections, and that abstraction helped found graph theory. Today it underpins internet routing, logistics, and the network analyses in many genetics papers. Had Euler typed the question into a chatbot and received "No," we might have the answer without the field. Navier-Stokes fits that pattern. The singularity result has no immediate practical payoff, and it stands on human shoulders. Both AI-assisted teams leaned heavily on a strategy from two human mathematicians, Diego Córdoba and Luis Martínez-Zoroa. Humans picked the approach that made the AI proof possible. There is a second worry: the pipeline. If a gifted 17-year-old reads a new "AI solves famous problem" headline every week, why commit a decade to a PhD? Clinical research has the same pipeline. If trainees decide the work is already done, we will run short of people who can tell when an AI-generated analysis is wrong. 3. Math is the easiest case for AI. Medicine is one of the hardest.Mathematics has something most fields lack: an answer key you can build. A proof is right or wrong, and Lean can check it. That checkability is why math fell first. Ethan Mollick calls this uneven pattern the jagged frontier: superhuman in some domains, unreliable in others. Code is checkable too, and labs have poured money into coding models. Yet senior engineers still wrap AI-generated code in tests, restricted permissions, and review, because the model does not know which question to ask. As someone building an AI research tool, I have never needed good engineers more. A clinical research question looks very different from a proof. Which confounders matter? Which outcome do patients care about? Is this association causal, or did we just measure who gets referred to an academic center? Medicine has no Lean. No answer key. When I left math behind for biology, I did not know I was picking the field AI would find hardest to master. 4. The Jevons paradox: why cheaper work creates more workIn 1865, the economist William Stanley Jevons published The Coal Question. Steam engines were getting more efficient, and many expected Britain to burn less coal. Jevons argued the opposite. Cheaper energy made steam power worth using in far more places, so total coal use climbed. When something gets cheaper to use, we find many more uses for it. ATMs. ATMs were supposed to end bank tellers. Between 1988 and 2004, the tellers needed per urban branch fell from 20 to 13. Branches got cheaper to run, banks opened 43% more of them, and teller jobs held. The work shifted from counting cash to solving problems and building relationships. Radiology. In 2016, Geoffrey Hinton said we should stop training radiologists. Since then, Mayo Clinic's radiology staff has grown 55% to 400 radiologists, alongside more than 250 AI models. Hinton has since said he spoke too broadly. Research. An LLM workflow called otto-SR reproduced and updated 12 Cochrane reviews in two days, work its authors estimated at roughly 12 work-years. A study in Science found that researchers who adopted LLMs produced roughly 24% to 89% more papers. When a review costs a fraction of what it used to, we will not run the same number with fewer people. We will run far more and chase the questions nobody had time for. And medicine's list of open questions is endless. Every one of those cheaper studies still needs a person to choose the question, judge the design, and decide what the answer means for a patient. 5. Jevons is not a guaranteeThe ATM story has a second chapter. Online and mobile banking emptied the branches, and the Bureau of Labor Statistics now projects a 13% decline in teller jobs from 2025 to 2035. The ATM did not cut teller jobs. The smartphone did. AI's early labor data are mixed too. A Stanford payroll analysis found a 16% relative employment decline for workers aged 22 to 25 in the most AI-exposed occupations, while experienced workers held steady. In science, a Nature study found that AI-adopting scientists published about three times as many papers and led teams 1.4 years earlier, yet the range of topics science studied shrank. Andrew Ng, Stanford professor and founder of multiple startups, puts the problem in training, not jobs. He has said he no longer hires engineers who still work the way they did before AI, and that university curricula have not kept pace. I have seen this firsthand when trying to learn AI. Because the university AI curricula has not kept pace, most of the courses I've taken are by individual creators or business people and then I try to apply it to academia. There is also one job AI cannot take: responsibility. AI can give every recommendation in the world, but someone has to own the decision. Medicine already wrote that rule down. The ICMJE bars AI from authorship because it cannot be held responsible for the accuracy and originality of the work. Your name goes on the paper. Your signature goes on the order. Accountability stays human, and so does the judgment that earns it. So the role stays. The rules change. The people who get hurt are the ones still trained for the old rules. You can be the dinosaur, staring at the incoming meteor and hoping it misses. Or you can be the surfer. You cannot change the wave. You can learn to ride it. 6. Five strategies to ride the AI wave:1. Move your time up the stack
2. Be the surfer
3. The role stays. The rules change.
4. Verify every step
5. Use ABZ instead of a 10-year plan
So what is the point of teaching the next generation?If Jevons is right, we will need more of them. But we will need to teach them differently. Less time on the parts with an answer key. Far more time on choosing questions, designing studies, spotting the confounder nobody named, and rejecting a plausible answer that happens to be wrong. Euler's lasting contribution was never the answer about the bridges. It was the way of thinking he built while getting there. As AI takes over more of the answer-key work, that way of thinking becomes most of the job. I am rationally optimistic. What is one research task AI has already taken off your plate? And what did you do with the time it gave back? Top Papers on AI in research this week:
Top Papers on AI in education this week:
The post AI Just Wrote 700+ Math Papers. Will It Replace Researchers? appeared first on Rising Researcher Academy. |