I Have Never Written a Blog Post Without AI. Including This One.Todayβs newsletter is brought to you by: That sentence makes some of my colleagues uncomfortable. It should not. By the end of this post, I hope you will agree on one thing: if we do not decide, on purpose, what to hand to AI and what to keep, the decision gets made for us. Randomly. It already is. Let me start somewhere far from academic writing. A hospital in Nepal. ππ½ Quick announcement: Learn how to use AI in research the right way in my 5-Week LIVE AI Academic Writing Accelerator (included with Research Boost subscription) β’ Starts September β’ Limited to 100 Seats β Reserve Your Seat HEREβ 1. The internship that ran on scut workIn medical school and internship in Nepal, a large part of my day was not medicine. It was logistics. I drew the blood. I carried the sample to the lab and walked back for the report. When a patient needed a higher center, I rode in the ambulance, sometimes bagging and masking the whole way. For a long time I believed that grind made me a doctor. I was wrong. Something did build judgment in those years, but it was not the blood draws. It was the moments in between. Presenting a patient to a senior and being asked why. Guessing sick or not sick before the labs came back. Thousands of small calls, each corrected by someone better than me. The scut work was the container. The loop inside it was the education. I got the loop by accident. 2. The loop without the scutMy residency in the United States was a different world. I never drew blood. I never pushed a stretcher. Almost all of my training was judgment, taught on purpose:
The method was explicit. Think out loud. Present your reasoning, not just your answer. Let the attending pull it apart. Present again tomorrow. Same loop as Nepal. Zero scut. My judgment grew faster because the loop was the whole day, not the 10 minutes between errands. Nobody should mourn the scut work. But residency here did something different: it decided what the intern's time was for. That is the decision we are failing to make with AI. Take the EHR. An AI summary of every rheumatology note in a chart is a real gift. But deciding what belongs in the history, what matters on exam, and how to reason through the assessment and plan is the skill the intern is there to build. Hand that to AI and the trainee gets faster today and worse for a decade. That is not a hypothetical. In a 2025 study of experienced endoscopists, a few months of working with AI-assisted colonoscopy was followed by a drop in their detection rate when the AI was switched off, from about 28 percent to 22 percent. Skilled clinicians, measurably worse at the core task after routine AI exposure. 3. The rest of the knowledge economy just caught upA recent newsletter piece describes what its author calls the "engineered apprenticeship." I will call it the engineered internship, our word in medicine and research. Law, tax, audit, and consulting have all arrived, in the past year, at the lesson medicine learned a generation ago. The argument is sharp. AI did not break training by making courses worse. It switched off the engine doing the real development: years of routine tasks, done near senior people whose reasoning rubbed off. AI took away the scut work. And with it, by accident, the loop hiding inside. The response has been the same everywhere: Big Law deposition simulators, a KPMG tax simulator, Deloitte's rebuilt audit program, PwC training first-years as reviewers of AI output from week one. Every build has three parts. A loop: make the call before you see the expert's answer, compare, go again on something harder. A captured expert: someone senior narrating why they made the call, so reasoning gets taught instead of absorbed by seating chart. A target: judgment that used to arrive in year five, taught from day one. 4. My own test case: writingI learned medical writing the traditional way (as most of you probably did). Case reports, then systematic reviews, then cohort studies. No course. I copied papers I admired and worked with whoever would have me. Years of reps, and almost nobody asking why I made the choices I made. It worked. It was slow. Then AI arrived, and I started doing something new: writing for a general audience. Blog posts. LinkedIn. Newsletters. Most of what I publish is AI-assisted in a big way. The research, the brainstorming, the structuring. If you took AI away tomorrow, I would struggle to write this post, because I never learned to do it the old way. And yet I am not worried. 5. What I actually trained: judgment and tasteI cannot write 10 great hooks from a blank page. But when AI gives me 10, I know which one is great. The one that stops someone scrolling at 11 pm. When a draft comes back, I can tell which paragraph is hollow, which claim I cannot stand behind, and which sentence does not sound like me. That skill came from studying what great looks like: which posts do well on LinkedIn, what a real hook does. AI produces. I judge. I am accountable for what goes out under my name. Judgment is knowing what good looks like before it exists. Taste is recognizing it the moment it shows up. Production is cheap now. Selection is not. 6. The gap AI widensOn routine tasks, AI narrows the gap between novices and experts. In the best-known study, customer support agents given an AI assistant got 14 percent more productive on average, but the least experienced gained 34 percent while the most experienced gained almost nothing. On complex tasks that need domain judgment, it widens it. Experts use AI to go further. Novices accept output that is plausible but generic. When consultants at a top firm used GPT-4 on a task just outside what the model does well, they were 19 percentage points less likely to get the right answer than colleagues with no AI at all. The output read well. It was wrong. Hand a fresh trainee an AI writing tool without teaching them to check it, and you do not close the gap between them and you. You compound it. They will produce a Discussion that reads smoothly and argues nothing, and they will not know the difference. A survey of knowledge workers found the pattern in miniature: the more people trusted the AI's answer, the less they checked it. That is the trainee who lost the loop along with the scut. 7. The real problem: nobody is decidingIn most labs right now, nobody has decided what trainees should outsource. So it happens by default. The research trainee uses AI for the literature search, which is fine. Then the first draft of the Introduction. Then the Discussion. Then interpreting the results. Then deciding what the paper is even claiming. Nobody chose that. It drifted, one convenient step at a time. Random outsourcing does not stop at the tasks that are safe to give away. It keeps going until it reaches the ones that should never be given away, and it cannot tell the difference. Residency solved this by being explicit. Scut work: outsourced. Presenting the assessment: never outsourced, practiced daily, corrected in public. Research training needs the same split, written down: Outsource freely. Literature retrieval. Formatting. Reference management. First-pass summaries of papers you will read anyway. Grammar and flow on a draft whose argument you already own. Keep for yourself, always. Interpreting your own data. The argument of the Discussion. Any number. Any citation you have not opened. The final read for voice. And the accountability for all of it. Make trainees practice on purpose. What the paper is really claiming. Which result matters most. What a reviewer will attack first. When a plausible AI sentence is quietly wrong. These are the "sick versus not sick" of manuscript writing, and they cannot be learned by watching AI do them. Your lists might differ from mine. Having them is what matters. 8. Running the loopOnce the lists exist, the loop is simple. Here is how I run it and how I am starting to run it with the people I mentor:
Every training program is making the outsourcing decision right now. And most are making it by not making it. People can tell AI slop from expert-led work. What separates them is whether a trained judgment made the calls at the steps that matter. That judgment no longer shows up on its own. It has to be built, and building it starts with a list. Top Papers on AI in research this week:
Top Papers on AI in education this week:
The post I Have Never Written a Blog Post Without AI. Including This One appeared first on Rising Researcher Academy.β |